• Our Services
  • Our Method
  • Team
  • Sales
  • Rentals
  • Furnished
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
  1. Home
  2. 434 East 58th Street, 4AB
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
  • View All Photos
  • View Floor Plans
  • Request an Appointment

434 East 58th Street, 4AB

Sutton Place | NY
First Avenue & York Avenue

Schedule a Viewing
$ 1,100,000
Active
Status
7
Rooms
2
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
1,250/116
ASF/ASM
$ 2,470
Maintenance [Monthly]
80%
Financing Allowed
  • 434 East 58th Street, 4AB
  • 7 Rooms
  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • $ 1,100,000

Photos

434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022

Floor Plans

434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022

Description

Oversized, fully renovated prewar two-bedroom, two-bath residence featuring two working wood-burning fireplaces and exceptionally low monthlies-what more could you ask for?

This is a rare opportunity to own a true combination home in a beautifully maintained prewar elevator building just off Sutton Place. Spanning approximately 1,250 square feet, the residence delivers impressive scale, architectural character, and outstanding value-an exceptional buy at $1.1M and well under $900 per square foot.

Two working wood-burning fireplaces with original mantelpieces serve as striking focal points and immediately distinguish the home-an increasingly scarce luxury in Manhattan. Solid oak hardwood floors run throughout, reinforcing the warm, classic prewar aesthetic. The layout is gracious yet highly flexible, offering generous living and dining areas, excellent storage, and a windowed office area (currently configured as an oversized walk-in closet).

The windowed kitchen has been thoughtfully renovated with marble countertops and hand-cut backsplash tile, marrying timeless materials with modern functionality. Stainless steel appliances include a dishwasher, microwave, oversized refrigerator, and abundant pantry storage. Both windowed bathrooms have been fully renovated and feature tubs and clean, enduring finishes, with natural stone in both baths.

Rich with prewar charm while offering the comfort and convenience today's buyers expect, the home is in true move-in condition. The boutique co-op features a laundry room, package area, and elevator. A ButterflyMX virtual doorman system allows for seamless keyless entry, rentals are permitted after two years of ownership, pied e terres are permitted, and there is storage available in the basement (on a first come first serve basis).

Set on a picturesque, tree-lined block, the location strikes the perfect balance between quiet residential living and everyday convenience. Just moments from Sutton Place and the East River Esplanade, and surrounded by neighborhood favorites including Trader Joe's, Whole Foods, and an excellent selection of restaurants, cafés, and shops. Multiple nearby subway lines provide easy access throughout the city. Note - some images have been virtually staged.

Space, character, condition, and value come together effortlessly here-an exceptional prewar home that truly delivers.

Oversized, fully renovated prewar two-bedroom, two-bath residence featuring two working wood-burning fireplaces and exceptionally low monthlies-what more could you ask for?

This is a rare opportunity to own a true combination home in a beautifully maintained prewar elevator building just off Sutton Place. Spanning approximately 1,250 square feet, the residence delivers impressive scale, architectural character, and outstanding value-an exceptional buy at $1.1M and well under $900 per square foot.

Two working wood-burning fireplaces with original mantelpieces serve as striking focal points and immediately distinguish the home-an increasingly scarce luxury in Manhattan. Solid oak hardwood floors run throughout, reinforcing the warm, classic prewar aesthetic. The layout is gracious yet highly flexible, offering generous living and dining areas, excellent storage, and a windowed office area (currently configured as an oversized walk-in closet).

The windowed kitchen has been thoughtfully renovated with marble countertops and hand-cut backsplash tile, marrying timeless materials with modern functionality. Stainless steel appliances include a dishwasher, microwave, oversized refrigerator, and abundant pantry storage. Both windowed bathrooms have been fully renovated and feature tubs and clean, enduring finishes, with natural stone in both baths.

Rich with prewar charm while offering the comfort and convenience today's buyers expect, the home is in true move-in condition. The boutique co-op features a laundry room, package area, and elevator. A ButterflyMX virtual doorman system allows for seamless keyless entry, rentals are permitted after two years of ownership, pied e terres are permitted, and there is storage available in the basement (on a first come first serve basis).

Set on a picturesque, tree-lined block, the location strikes the perfect balance between quiet residential living and everyday convenience. Just moments from Sutton Place and the East River Esplanade, and surrounded by neighborhood favorites including Trader Joe's, Whole Foods, and an excellent selection of restaurants, cafés, and shops. Multiple nearby subway lines provide easy access throughout the city. Note - some images have been virtually staged.

Space, character, condition, and value come together effortlessly here-an exceptional prewar home that truly delivers.


Listing Courtesy of Serhant LLC

Features

A/C

View / Exposure

City Views
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022

Building Details

434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022
Co-op
Ownership
Low-Rise
Building Type
Video Intercom
Service Level
Elevator
Access
No Pets
Pet Policy
1369/33
Block/Lot
Pre-War
Age
1930
Year Built
6/23
Floors/Apts

Building Amenities

Laundry Room
Private Storage
434 East 58th Street 4AB Sutton Place New York NY 10022

Contact

License Licensed As: Jay M. Heydt
Jay Heydt

Jay Heydt

License Licensed As: Jay M. Heydt

Principal Broker

W: 646-234-5815
M: 646-234-5815
Contact Agent Download VCard

Mortgage Calculator

$
%
$
%

Loan Amount

This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2026 REBNY Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. All information is intended only for the Registrant’s personal, non-commercial use. RLS Data display by Vertical Real Estate. Additional building data provided by On-Line Residential [OLR].
All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
Listing ID: 1609120